Run Game Conversation

The friend zone: how to tell, and what to do about it

5 min read

"The friend zone" is a popular phrase for a situation where one person wants something romantic and the other wants a friendship. People use it differently. Some use it for a painful gap between what they feel and what they've been told. Others dislike the phrase because it treats friendship as a consolation prize and the friend as a gatekeeper.

Both views are common, and you don't have to pick one. This post sticks to what you can do: work out what you're in, say what you feel once, and take the answer you get. Friendship is a real outcome, and so is a clear no.

What the research says about attraction between friends

One often-cited study is Bleske-Rechek and colleagues (2012), published in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships. In the first part, 88 pairs of heterosexual college students who were friends answered questions about the friendship. On average, the men reported more attraction to their female friend than the women reported toward their male friend, and the men overestimated how attracted their friend was to them. In the second part, with young adults (average age 19) and an older group (142 people, average age 37, about 90% married), 32% of participants on average listed attraction as a cost or complication of the friendship, about five times as often as they listed it as a benefit. Men more often than women listed it as a benefit.

The limits are worth reading too. The samples were heterosexual, mostly college students or married adults, and the data was self-reported. The authors described their evolutionary explanation as only preliminary support, and the study is correlational. These are group averages. They don't say what your friend feels.

What you can take from it is modest: people misjudge each other's feelings in cross-sex friendships, and attraction can complicate them for both sides. That's an argument for asking and telling, and against guessing for months.

How to tell whether it's friendship, or a waiting room

You can't read her mind, but you can check your own side honestly.

If you're not sure whether she's being friendly or interested, is she being friendly or flirting and how to tell if someone is interested cover observable signals, with the reminder that they're hints, not certainties.

Say it once, clearly

A common, pressure-free answer to "how do I get out of the friend zone" is to tell her how you feel and let her answer. Her answer decides it, not a technique. How to tell a friend you like her covers how to bring it up in full. The short version:

Don't make it a speech, a gift, or a grand gesture. A large, public one can leave her feeling cornered.

After her answer

If she says yes, go slowly and ask her on a real date. Friends who become partners still start with a first date, and she may want time to adjust.

If she says no, a few things help, as common advice, not rules:

How to get over a girl who didn't like you back and seeing her again after a no go into the next few weeks.

If she says "I don't know," that's a hesitation, not a yes. You can tell her to take her time, and you don't need to wait on her indefinitely. Decide what you're willing to do in the meantime.

What not to do

If you've never been on the other side, remember that she's in a hard spot as well. She may value you a lot and worry about losing the friendship.

What to do next

  1. Answer the four honest questions above on paper: would I stay without romance, am I keeping score, how do I react to her dates, how long has it been.
  2. Decide what outcome you can live with before you say anything: yes, no with friendship, or no with distance.
  3. Choose a time and place this week where she can answer privately and without an audience.
  4. Write your one-sentence version and say it aloud twice. Keep it under 25 words.
  5. Plan the day after. If she says no, line up a friend to see, a workout, or plans so you're not alone with it.
  6. Expand your own circle. Meeting other people, through hobbies and classes or making friends as an adult, means your social life doesn't hinge on one person.

If it helps to think it through with other people, the Mindset topic in the Run Game forum is one place to ask.

Sources