Run Game Conversation

People-watching as a social skill: what to notice

6 min read

You can practice reading a room without saying a word to anyone. Sit somewhere busy, watch for fifteen minutes, and write down what you saw. That's people-watching, and it's a cheap way to build a feel for how conversations start, who's open to one and who's busy, and how groups arrange themselves.

It has a hard limit, though. Watching teaches you what a situation looks like. It doesn't teach you what it feels like to speak first. Treat it as a warm-up for talking to people, never a replacement.

What to notice

How groups stand

The researcher Adam Kendon studied how people physically arrange themselves when they talk, and called the result an F-formation. In his account, two people might stand face to face, at a right angle, or side by side looking the same way, and bigger groups often form a circle. The space in the middle is one that each person can reach equally and that outsiders don't have access to, and the group keeps it that way through its behavior. The EMCA Wiki's summary adds that newcomers can change a formation by stepping in and greeting people, and that people leave by drifting away.

You can use that as a watching exercise. Is a group in a tight circle with backs to the room, or is it loose with a gap? Does anyone at the edge get pulled in? Notice how long it takes. Read it as information about one group on one night, not a rule.

Where people talk

William H. Whyte spent years photographing and mapping city sidewalks and plazas. A 1989 Christian Science Monitor profile reports that street conversations tended to settle in the thick of the heaviest foot traffic, not in quiet spots off to the side. It's one researcher's observation of specific places, but it's a good prompt: where do people actually stop and chat in the place you're sitting? Doorways, queues, the end of the counter?

Who looks busy and who looks open

Make a list of what you can see, and keep it to behavior. Someone typing fast with headphones on is probably occupied. Someone looking around the room, standing without a task, or glancing at the door might be waiting and receptive. Might. You're guessing.

That caution is backed by research. At the University of Kansas, Jeffrey Hall and Seth Brooks had 52 pairs of single heterosexual college students talk for 10 to 12 minutes (published 2014 in Communication Research). The pairs spotted when their partner wasn't flirting more than 80 percent of the time, but caught actual flirting only 36 percent (men) and 18 percent (women) of the time. A second study with more than 250 observers watching one-minute clips did no better. It was a small student sample in a lab and it was about flirting, not conversation in general. Still, it suggests that reading strangers from the outside is hard, and that your best guesses should stay as guesses.

How conversations open

Pick one exchange between strangers and watch how it starts. Who spoke first? Was it about the surroundings, a shared wait, an object? How long before the other person asked something back? You're collecting real openings, which beat any list of lines.

Watching without staring

Erving Goffman, in Behavior in Public Places (1963), described civil inattention: a brief, subtle acknowledgment of a stranger followed by looking away, which sits between ignoring someone and starting an encounter. Most public life runs on it, and it's a decent guide for you. Glance, don't hold the gaze. Keep your attention on the scene as a whole instead of on one person.

A few practical limits:

A 15-minute café routine

Pick a café, food court or bench with steady foot traffic. Bring a notes app or a pocket notebook.

  1. Minutes 0 to 3: Settle in. Look at the whole room, not at people yet. Where do people cluster? Where's the flow?
  2. Minutes 3 to 7: Find three groups or pairs. For each, write one line on how they're standing or sitting and whether the group looks closed or loose.
  3. Minutes 7 to 11: Find one person alone and write down what they're doing, as behavior only ("reading, phone face down, glancing up when the door opens"). Then write what you'd guess about whether they're up for a chat, and mark it as a guess.
  4. Minutes 11 to 14: Watch for one conversation starting, anywhere in the room. Write down who opened and how.
  5. Minute 15: Rehearse once in your head. Imagine yourself in the setting, with a plain, short line that fits it ("Is that as good as it looks?" to someone eyeing the pastry case). You're not going to use it today. You're just practicing hearing yourself say it.

Do this twice a week for a few weeks and you'll start noticing patterns without trying.

Where watching stops being useful

In the lab, a pattern called the liking gap shows up. Erica Boothby and colleagues (2018, Psychological Science) ran five studies, with samples from 34 students in the first up to 100 people in workshops, and found that people consistently underestimated how much their conversation partner liked them after talking. The gap showed up whether the chat lasted 2 or 45 minutes, and it was larger for shyer people. The studies drew on students, members of the public and entrepreneurs, and none of them were about dating. They point to something people often notice: the gap between what you imagine will happen and what happens once you talk. Watching can't tell you what your partner thought of you. Talking to people can.

If you notice you've watched for three sessions and your notes are getting longer while your conversations aren't getting more frequent, that's the signal to switch. Say hello to the barista. Ask the person next to you in line a question about the line.

What to do next

  1. Do the 15-minute café routine twice this week, on different days and at different times.
  2. In each session, write down three observations about how people stand and one about how a conversation opened.
  3. Mark every guess about someone's mood or interest as a guess, then pay attention to how often you can't tell.
  4. After the second session, say one short line to a stranger in a low-stakes setting, such as a cashier or someone in a queue, and note how it went.
  5. Keep a running list of the openings you saw that sounded natural, and compare it to the ones you'd use.

If you use Run Game, a session can have notes, so a few lines on what you noticed before you go out can sit right next to your log. For related reading, see reading the room, reading other people's body language, warming up before you go out, and how to start a conversation with a stranger.

It pairs well with being a better listener.

Sources